During COVID, every developer was terrified that their costs were going to run way from them. According to this recent Globe and Mail article, residential building costs increased 55% since 2020. At the same time, city fees were being increased and some people, for whatever reason, believed this would not have an impact on home prices. Developers will always seek to profit maximize and charge whatever the market will bear, so why bother trying to reduce costs? This is/was one school of thought.

Despite this cost fear, the market managed to keep up for a period of time. Capital was cheap, as we all know. And that kept things going, until it was no longer the case. According to the same Globe article, there are 83 residential projects and 28,428 homes that have not launched (sales) over the last two years in the Greater Toronto Area because of market conditions. This year alone, the number is estimated at 14,000 homes. So supply has fallen off, and that's because demand and buying power have fallen off.

But let's think of this in economics terms. Price and quantity demanded are usually inversely correlated. Meaning, if the price of something goes up, demand will go down. And if the price of something goes down, demand will go up. So in theory, there are still prices that will get 28,428 people excited to buy a new home. I mean, if I were to list a condo in downtown Toronto for $500 psf right now, I'm pretty sure that most with the means would jump at the opportunity.

The problem is that whatever these prices are, they are largely beneath the floor price of where most developers can build to today. Developers weren't bluffing, costs really are too high now. And when this happens, the answer is simple: you can't build. A new equilibrium will eventually be found. But in the short-term, we should all expect new housing supply to remain limited. And because there's always a lag with real estate, the effects of this shortage will be felt in the years to come.

During COVID, every developer was terrified that their costs were going to run way from them. According to this recent Globe and Mail article, residential building costs increased 55% since 2020. At the same time, city fees were being increased and some people, for whatever reason, believed this would not have an impact on home prices. Developers will always seek to profit maximize and charge whatever the market will bear, so why bother trying to reduce costs? This is/was one school of thought.

Despite this cost fear, the market managed to keep up for a period of time. Capital was cheap, as we all know. And that kept things going, until it was no longer the case. According to the same Globe article, there are 83 residential projects and 28,428 homes that have not launched (sales) over the last two years in the Greater Toronto Area because of market conditions. This year alone, the number is estimated at 14,000 homes. So supply has fallen off, and that's because demand and buying power have fallen off.

But let's think of this in economics terms. Price and quantity demanded are usually inversely correlated. Meaning, if the price of something goes up, demand will go down. And if the price of something goes down, demand will go up. So in theory, there are still prices that will get 28,428 people excited to buy a new home. I mean, if I were to list a condo in downtown Toronto for $500 psf right now, I'm pretty sure that most with the means would jump at the opportunity.

The problem is that whatever these prices are, they are largely beneath the floor price of where most developers can build to today. Developers weren't bluffing, costs really are too high now. And when this happens, the answer is simple: you can't build. A new equilibrium will eventually be found. But in the short-term, we should all expect new housing supply to remain limited. And because there's always a lag with real estate, the effects of this shortage will be felt in the years to come.