The general rule when it comes to bike lanes is that, if you build them without some sort of grade-separation, at some point a car is going to park in them. But here are two possible solutions to this problem. The first is that you could build some sort of grade-separation that can't be driven over. And the second is as follows:
Now a New York City Council member is pushing a bill that would give civilians the power to report bike lane scofflaws, as well as vehicles that block entrances or exits of school buildings, sidewalks and crosswalks. New Yorkers who submit evidence of a parking violation can earn 25% of a proposed $175 ticket. The Department of Transportation would review the evidence to determine whether an infraction has occurred, according to the bill’s text.
What this essentially does is decentralize rule enforcement by paying people to be rats. Off hand, I can't think of any other cities that have done something like this and so I don't know how effective it might actually be. But being a rat sounds like it could be a good paying job.
Let's assume that somebody decided to treat this as their full-time job and work 8 hours a day, Monday to Friday. And then let's assume that they were able to rat out one person per hour. Here's how much money they could make in a year:
$175 x 25% = $43.75 per illegal incident
$43.75 x 8 incidents per day = $350 per day
$350 per day x 5 days a week = $1,750 per week
$1,750 per week x 52 weeks = $91,000 per year
Now, if the goal of this rat-people-out program is to ultimately change behaviors, then it might make sense to assume that your revenues would decline over time as more people start following the rules. Either way, something tells me that more than a few people would be happy to take on this job.
I love High Park. It's the second largest green space in the City of Toronto and right beside the Junction neighborhood. But there are some problems. Despite having a subway line on its northern boundary, we've gotten the built form along its edges all wrong.
There's very little functioning retail. The densities and heights are not nearly high enough. The streets aren't great walking streets. And we've even gone and created undignified bus stops like this one here.
On top of all this, we're now doing this silly thing where police are ticketing cyclists for riding around the park with too much vigor and enthusiasm. I'm sure somebody called to complain and this is all reactionary politics, but an even bigger reaction has now been set off.
For those of you who haven't been following or aren't from Toronto, hundreds of cyclists took to the streets this week to peacefully protest what has been going on in High Park.
The Globe & Mail then followed it up with this important piece calling for an end to cars inside the park. The boundaries currently house about 5 km of roads and almost 600 parking spots.
https://twitter.com/jamespmcleod/status/1557853074542272514?s=20&t=jUSwdRpiiOfSbNXsfMIKCQ
Given all this, I figured now is probably a good time to revive one of Casey Neistat's original YouTube videos called "bike lanes." The story is that he gets a ticket for not riding in a bike lane. And so he films a video of himself only riding in bike lanes -- even if there are obstacles in his way.
https://youtu.be/bzE-IMaegzQ
It's an awesome video with nearly 30 million views. And I'm sure that many of you have felt like doing exactly what he does when faced with this same situation. I know I have.
https://youtu.be/2wH7STjPXKU
It's one thing to have bike lanes. And it's another thing to have really generous bike lanes. The above video by Streetfilms does a good job of comparing Paris to New York City, and showing just how far Paris has come in terms of cycling infrastructure. Some of you might remember that in the fall of last year, Paris announced plans to become a "100% cycling city." This was a follow-on to their plan vélo 2015-2020, which saw a doubling of the city's bike lanes. The current plan, which covers 2021-2026, includes 130 km of new bike lanes and 52 km of pandemic lanes that have been (or will be) made permanent. But again, it's one thing to have a lot of bike lanes. And it's another thing to have a lot of wide bike lanes that look like the ones in this video.
