Last year, the Feds lowered immigration targets in response to Canadians getting grouchy about the number people entering the country. This is expected to be felt starting this year. RBC estimates that Canada's overall population will shrink by about 0.2% this year and next, before returning to positive growth in 2027 (albeit at a lower rate).
That said, the data we have at our disposal today is backward looking and for the 12 months ending on July 1, 2024, Canada continued to see impressive population growth. Looking at the Greater Golden Horseshoe specifically, it grew by about 382,000 people. The 2023 figure was also revised upward from 340,000 to 367,000.
Here's a table from TMU's Centre for Urban Research and Land Development:
Nearly three-quarters of this growth was concentrated in the Greater Toronto Area, and about three-quarters of this growth was concentrated in Toronto and Peel at 143,000 and 70,000 people, respectively. These are big numbers, especially during a period of dramatically fewer housing starts.
Of course, going forward, lower household formation should alleviate some of the pressures on our housing market. But zero population growth is not sustainable, not unless we want to end up like Japan with a demographic crisis. So there will be tremendous market pressures to return to positive growth.
At the same time, if we go back to RBC's insight report, it specifically says: "This [lower immigration levels] will help realign housing demand with supply — so long as homebuilding can be sustained near current levels." Yeah, that's not happening. Housing starts in the Toronto region have fallen off a cliff.
So I continue to feel like 2027 will mark an important turning point for our housing market. It could be the year when population growth broadly returns, when we've fully absorbed the supply from the last cycle, and when we suddenly realize we don't have nearly enough new housing. Or at least that's my view.
Cover photo by Richard Hong on Unsplash
Bullpen Consulting just released its Q3-2024 high-rise land report for the Greater Toronto Area. Here's a figure showing average high-density land prices (on a per buildable square foot) by quarter since 2018:
Here's their summary data broken out by Toronto versus the Greater Toronto Area:
And here's a list of all the land transactions last quarter:
At the highest level, the average high-density land trade last quarter across the GTA was at around $98 per buildable square foot. This is down 13% from $112 pbsf in Q3-2023. And going back to the first chart in this post, there also seems to be a longer-term decline in high-density land prices.
But as Bullpen rightly points out in their report, there are limits to what can be gleaned from data like this. And that's because land transactions can be structured in countless ways. Did the vendor provide cheap financing? Was there a delayed close? Are there any unique site conditions that could be impacting value? The list goes on.
So even though prices and transaction volumes are down (which is what one would totally expect right now), it still doesn't feel like this data accurately reflects what's going on in the market today. I think the reality is worse.
If you'd like to join Bullpen's mailing list, here's their website.
Figures: Bullpen Research & Consulting
It is based on recent population estimates from Statistics Canada, and what it is saying is that the Greater Toronto Area grew by 233,000 people during the 12 months ending July 1, 2023. If you include Hamilton, this number increases to 246,000. And if you include the entire Greater Golden Horseshoe, it increases to 340,000.
This is significantly more population growth compared to any of the six preceding years. And assuming this 2021 population estimate of about 9.8 million people is more or less correct, it represents an almost 3.5% growth rate. That's remarkable. It's also happening at a time when housing starts are declining.
