Daily insights for city builders, delivered every morning at 6 AM ET. I’m Brandon Donnelly — a Toronto-based real estate developer and founder of Globizen. I’ve been writing here since 2013.

When does vandalism become art?

“I think that street art is illegal and it has to stay illegal.” –Invader

I was in an Uber on the Don Valley Parkway today and, for some reason, all of the graffiti on its sound barriers caught my attention in a way that it hasn’t before. Maybe it’s because I don’t travel enough by car or maybe the highway people haven’t yet done their spring cleaning. Either way, I caught myself thinking, “Hey, a lot of this looks pretty cool. Here are boring and utilitarian sound barriers that have been covered with colorful things.”

Of course, street art is a tricky thing. Because, at the end of the day, it is, as French artist Invader says, illegal. It is an act of vandalism. And so there is a fine line between street art and criminal behaviour. When I leave my home in the morning and I discover that someone has spray painted nonsense on one of its exterior walls, it absolutely pisses me off. How about I come spray paint your home?

But what if it wasn’t nonsense? What if Invader had decided to “invade” Toronto and I instead found a pixelated neon green Pac-Man outside of my lobby? It would still be illegal and it would still be vandalism, but I would frankly feel excited that Invader had decided to come and bestow my home with one of his art pieces. I would then proceed to take a picture and send it to all of my family and friends.

Now, obviously it makes a difference when it’s a known artist. Context matters. But Invader had to start his illegal pursuits somewhere. And I find it interesting to think about the line where something is able to pass, in our minds, from being an illegal nuisance to a desirable art piece. I experienced moments of that along the Don Valley Parkway today.

One response to “When does vandalism become art?”

  1. Sam Avatar
    Sam

    I believe the rainbow tunnel would have (and was) considered graffiti at the time. Now it is iconic so it did become art at some point!

    https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/don-valley-parkway-rainbow-gets-a-makeover/article_ea19cbaa-2928-5b7f-855e-4015993785dd.html

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *